Issue #116: Dear CPG Founders

Dear CPG Founders

Last week, big news swept the CPG ecosystem with Mondelez’s acquisition of Undercover Snacks. In Issue #115, I shared my thoughts on why that acquisition was such a win-win for both sides, as well as how this transaction should be a blueprint for how large CPG conglomerates should approach M&A. Inspired by that piece and all the great feedback I received, I thought I would flip the thesis on its head and share advice for CPG founders on how to approach building a company from the early days with an exit in mind.

Based on the current market, I think CPG founders really have two options to create a successful exit for themselves and investors. (I will caveat this statement with this: depending on the vertical, the $25-50M funds raised is a weird gray area for which way to proceed)

  1. Raise $50M or less: Build a brand in one subcategory and be ready to exit around $100-300M in annual sales. The product could be set up for expansion or further growth using the large CPG’s network effects.

  2. Raise $50M or more: Be an upstart conglomerate. You will need a central theme tying together the brands, but the idea here is to challenge the existing conglomerates, not become part of them.

For example #1, I would look no further than what Undercover Snacks did, and what Graza is attempting to do. Undercover had raised roughly $14M in outside capital, and turned that into an estimated $100M in annual sales, as well as an estimated $300M purchase price. Similarly, Graza raised just under $3M in total outside capital. Now, as previously reported, it is exploring a sale at a valuation between $450M and $600M, after launching expansion into adjacent categories like mayo and chips. I do not think Graza is trying to become a conglomerate with these product launches; I just think it is trying to justify an outsized multiple by showing potential expansion opportunities. Graza is only doing under $100M in revenue, so the valuation would be a steeper multiple than current transaction averages and even some outliers.

On the other side, for example #2, two brands immediately come to mind: Medici Brands and Mammoth Brands. You may not be familiar with these conglomerates, but you almost certainly are familiar with their sub-brands. Medici Brands most recently raised a $250M Series B, valuing it at ~$2.3B. Medici is best known for its David brand, which started in protein bars, and recently expanded to ready-to-drink shakes. It also has more emerging brands: Hallpass (candy) and Rowdy (salty snacks). The central theme here is that all the brands use a patented, proprietary ingredient, EPG, which allows for much lower-calorie versions of everyday staples.

Mammoth Brands most recently raised $155M at a $1.7B valuation in 2021. Its core brand is Harry’s (men’s personal care), and it has also created Mando (whole-body deodorant for men) and Flamingo (women’s personal care). Mammoth has also acquired brands Lume (women’s whole-body deodorant) and Coiterie (premium baby). Here, there is less of a proprietary ingredient tying everything together, as opposed to a framework of focusing on innovating in the under-innovated personal care industry and focusing on products that can be direct-to-consumer. Both are examples of a core pillar to tie brands together, whether it’s an operating framework or a proprietary ingredient.

As a founder, is there a right choice? I think sometimes there can be signals, but at the end of the day it is up to you to decide as a founder what you want for the business. There are strengths and weaknesses to both models; it just depends more on your ideas for the company and category(s). Do you want to build a challenger brand or challenger conglomerate? Very different strategies to follow with either choice.

If you were the founder of a CPG brand, which type of business would you want to build?

Login or Subscribe to participate

This week in retail 11/15

Amazon Expands Grocery Initiatives After Early Success

With Q3 wrapping up, that means earnings calls! There was plenty of interesting news coming out of this cycle, but one call that stood out to me was Amazon’s. It should not come as a surprise that grocery shoppers’ frequency leads to more orders and engagement. What is a surprise to me is the sheer magnitude of Amazon’s grocery initiative. Here are some of the standout stats from the call.

  • Amazon’s fresh groceries and everyday essentials assortments grew approximately three times faster than the rest of its store

  • Fresh groceries and everyday essentials are about half of all units sold during Q3

  • Perishables and everyday essentials gross sales are almost $250B over the past year (what are everyday essentials?)

  • Whole Foods Market is growing faster than the rest of Amazon’s other grocery segments

  • Customers who purchase perishables with same-day delivery buy nearly seven times more everyday essential units than those who don’t

  • Active grocery customers shop nearly four times more non-grocery categories like home and apparel and spend more than double on those categories compared to non-grocery shoppers

  • “We feel like we found something with shipping perishables out of our same-day facilities” - Andy Jassy, Amazon President & CEO

Jetty Launches In Whole Foods Market, Its First Retailer

Allison and Stephen Ellsworth may not be a household name yet, but the drink they started certainly is. They founded Poppi, the better-for-you prebiotic soda Pepsi purchased for almost $2B in 2025. Surprisingly, they didn’t have to, or were not incentivized to, stick around for long, and are already back in the beverage market, creating a competitor to what might be Pepsi’s biggest brand, Gatorade. They launched Jetty, which is a hydration brand geared for more casual consumption. The label literally says “Not for a marathon. Not for the gym.”

The market has been shifting to more hydration-oriented beverages rather than sports drinks, just look at Gatorade and all the sub-brands it has launched recently. It is clear customers want this type of product, but whether Jetty is the solution they are looking for, I am not so sure. Poppi was a genuine innovation in the market, even if the health claims turned out to be more dubious. I struggle to see that here. However, I do think it is very smart they launched in Whole Foods first, as there is definitely a gap in the premium end of the market for this type of product. It will be interesting to see how the product ends up doing, and if it is enough to break through the noise. Just look at Coca-Cola and Body Armor. That has not turned out too well.

What Is Going On With Agentic Commerce?

Agentic commerce has been the buzz of the commerce industry recently. Consumers seem to be genuinely bullish on it, but when it comes down to it, they do not seem to be actually using it for commerce. Whether that is consumers not actually doing what they say they are interested in, or if it is actually poor tracking on the retailer’s side, or if it is probably something in the middle, it seems agentic is underwhelming. Luckily for the customer insights nerds like myself, McKinsey just analyzed 21,000 customers’ behavior. I wanted to share some of my favorite insights below.

  • 53% of consumers now use AI for shopping, but the US lags the global average at 48%

  • In the United States, users completing a purchase with AI jumped 70% year-over-year

  • Traditional AI tools are used much more frequently than Retailer AI assistants during the shopping process, but the checkout process is pretty equally happening in the two types of tools

  • AI search is 3x more influential than traditional search

  • Gen Zers and millennials are more likely to use AI for shopping than older consumers

  • Grocery and apparel are leading the way for actually completing purchases, but we are still very much in the early innings (sub 20% of respondents), and interestingly are categories where total eCommerce lags

  • ChatGPT, Gemini, and Amazon in that order are the top three AI assistants for commerce

  • Consumers use AI tools to help them narrow down choices, scroll and click less, and save time

Additional Links:

  1. What happened to the Kraft Heinz merger

  2. American shoppers are no longer stocking up the pantry like they once did

  3. L'Oreal says weight loss drugs, like GLP-1s, are increasing beauty and skincare sales

  4. Oatly plans to make fiber-forward products

  5. How should brands think about growing in a regional independent grocer

  6. Customers are increasing online grocery spend but cutting back in other areas

  7. Anthropologie is commissioning creator-created shows instead of posts

  8. Quince is expanding its marketplace beyond just its private label to third-party brands

  9. Walmart more than doubles planned drone delivery sites

  10. Grocery Outlet’s comps return to positive after three quarters of negative comps

Events:

  • Wednesday, November 18, 6:30 PM - 8:30 PM - UGLY TALK: CPG FOUNDERS, WHAT WORKED, WHAT DIDN'T & THE 2027 OUTLOOK (sign up here)

  • Friday, December 11, All Day - Founders & Funders (sign up here)

  • Thursday, December 17, 7:00 PM - 9:30 PM, Lace the Halls: A Holiday Party w/ Brex and VHS Ventures (sign up here)

Ad:

The holiday streaming season is almost here

Are you ready? As revealed in our holiday playbook, Roku Ads Manager lets you easily set up, measure and optimize your self-serve holiday ad campaign. You can even create a shoppable ad unit that lets streamers buy directly from their remote.

Was this forwarded to you? Sign up here.

Have an idea or want to chat? Respond to this email.

Is the email not reaching your inbox? Try this trick.