Issue #117: Meadow Lane Hits $11M ARR

Before we dive in, a brief call to action for this community. Unfortunately, Gopuff went through some organizational changes this week, which means some awesome, incredibly talented people lost their jobs. I know many people reading this are hiring themselves or have portfolio companies hiring. If you have opportunities you are looking to fill, do not hesitate to send them my way! I am happy to connect you with some phenomenal talent for them!

Meadow Lane Hits $11M ARR

There is something about this time of year that screams accountability. Maybe it’s the new year’s resolutions you may or may not have missed. Maybe it’s the last-minute push to hit your numbers before the end of the year. Whatever reason it is, accountability seems to be everywhere. In my case, it is with regard to Meadow Lane, the c-store/bodega/grocery store hybrid in Tribeca founded by a famous TikToker, Sammy Nussdorf. I was skeptical it would succeed. Here are some of my thoughts in the past:

❝

Meadow Lane - Located in Tribeca and founded by TikToker Sammy Nussdorf, Meadow Lane is a premium grocery store featuring prepared foods and grocery staples. The store is very carefully curated and designed. Nussdorf has been documenting the entire process on his TikTok, which has helped generate buzz around the store launch.

❝

It feels like every month a new trendy grocery store is popping up. The characteristics of these stores tend to be very similar. Small footprint, low SKU count, good lighting, wooden shelves, space to walk in the aisles, and many grab-and-go items. At first, there will be a line out the door at the store when it blows up on social media, and then the hype will die down. For some, it will still be integral to their lives, but for most, they will stop going. All these markets popping up are not a coincidence.

These changes are going to be happening more and more as customers look for alternatives beyond the traditional conventional and club grocery stores that are increasingly dominating the landscape. With the new wave of consumers indicating they are more likely to shop at multiple stores each week, these smaller format specialty stores could carve out a niche. Still, I would surmise it will be difficult to scale these to dominant players given the smaller format and high prices. I anticipate a constant cycle of stores entering and exiting the space. For brands, these stores can be a strong sales outlet, just be careful not to overextend the slotting and entrance fees.

It is safe to say I was skeptical of the concept. What does a TikToker know about operating a retail grocery store? Well, it turns out a decent amount; as in the video above, Sammy shared some of the highlights of year one as he is building in public.

  • $11.7M in net sales during the first year of business

  • $1M in sales from the hot chicken tenders, representing 68k orders, and another 35k orders of the cold chicken tenders

  • ~1M units sold

  • 332k transactions

  • $35.17 average transaction value, but delivery orders see an AOV of $54

  • Top CPG items include Ballerina Farms, Masa Chips, and Loonen Still Water

  • October 2026 was the highest month of sales for the business, with November on pace to surpass those numbers, spurred by more, smaller transactions

I still remain skeptical this business can really scale across multiple locations and grow much further than the current ARR, but I certainly did not anticipate it hitting these heights. For context, the average bodega in NYC does $1-2M in revenue, and the average grocery store does $6-20M in revenue. These numbers would place it comparable to an average grocery store in NYC. The top ones are hitting $30M plus per location. A full P&L is being released in partnership with a business school case study early next year, according to Nussdorf, which I am very excited about diving into. It will be interesting to see what profit margins, if any, exist for this business.

Did you think Meadow Lane would succeed?

Login or Subscribe to participate

Yough Announces $4M Fundraise

The frozen space continues to heat up. This week, Yough, a better-for-you frozen pizza made with Greek yogurt in the crust to boost macros, announced a $4M fundraise led by Selva Ventures and Carter Comstock, a co-founder of Freshly. Yough was one of the brands that has been leading the emerging brand wave at Target; it launched in March in 2,000 stores and has been the #1 frozen pizza since, per the brand. Yough has expanded beyond Target to be in about 500 other locations, mostly Sprouts and Fresh Thyme. It is on pace to do $16M in retail sales for the year, which puts my estimates at least 10 units / $123 sales per store per week. Pretty impressive for a new brand. Customers are looking for their old favorites, but with more nutrients, which Yough hits squarely on the head.

Move Over Customer Insights, AI Digital Twins Are Here

Consumer brands worldwide spend an estimated $20B on customer analytics. The value from those analytics tends to outpace that spend, but it is so costly because gathering all that information is very expensive. It also can be very unreliable if not done properly, which often stems from the numeric scales over the qualitative responses. With the rise in AI, software platforms have been looking for new ways to gather information and test products. One of those companies was PyMC Labs, which was trying to duplicate customer surveys using AI personas. Early efforts failed because just asking the LLM skews results. The major unlock here was training the LLM to be a specific persona and use text-based responses to questions based on the training. Then, they partnered with Colgate-Palmolive to validate the surveys. Across 57 real personal care surveys with 9,300 human responses, which, to be fair, is pretty low per survey, the AI responses achieved 90% of human reliability. That last 10% will be the hardest to close, but I can totally see how this method going forward is going to be the default for customer research. For those interested, I have linked the full paper below.

Chomps Raises $350M From Sixth Street

Every rule has an exception. I spent the last two weeks opining on how both startups and large enterprises should approach capital raises and M&A going forward. Issue #115 focused on how large CPGs should approach M&A, while #116 was more about capital-raising strategy for startup CPG founders. This week, Chomps broke all the rules by raising $350M. No valuation was disclosed yet. Threw those thoughts right to the side.

For those unaware, Chomps, a more premium meat stick company, does $1B in annual revenue across 65k retail doors. Even with those lofty numbers, it only owns a 10% share of the category and 22% household penetration. Chomps is the fastest-growing meat snack brand in the country, according to SPINS. It has been expanding into convenience stores and other non-grocery channels. Chomps is the rare exception to the rule, but it is a good lesson. If you can get going in a $ 10B-plus category, that allows you to stay independent for a while, or forever. It will be interesting to see if Chomps attempts an IPO or an acquisition. Nonetheless, it is positioned for strength, even before looking at potential category expansion.

Deloitte Finds High-Value Grocery Stores Are Top For Shoppers

It is no secret that customers are seeking value in their shopping these days. Value can be derived from many things, not just price. Deloitte took a look at the specific behaviors, driving the decisions, and I pulled out some of my favorites:

  • 40% of US consumers are now value seekers, including 23% of households earning more than $200k

  • Brand value perceptions live in consumers’ heads, and are often conflating price with other factors that are really driving it

  • Value doesn’t equal cheap; some discounter brands have high absolute-value scores, but many fail to achieve more value for price status

  • Several premium and specialty-format store brands have low absolute-value scores yet achieve more value for price status despite higher prices

  • Using credit card transaction data from approximately 20M consumers, more value for price grocers recorded 13.9% spending growth compared with 3.9% for less value for price grocers

  • Beyond price, selection, cleanliness, store layout, and quality play major roles in value

  • Consumers value higher-quality produce and bakery because if they are just discarding poor quality, they aren’t saving any money

In many instances, consumers don’t really understand what drives their own value equation, which makes it even harder for brands and retailers to understand what drives their own value. Fun challenges to unpack! Maybe this is where the AI tools will be able to help more.

Additional Links:

  1. The Great De-Conglomeration Scorecard, breaking down Kraft Heinz’s decision to cancel the breakup

  2. How Crosta Mollica tripled sales and joined a €1bn European pizza group

  3. The rule of 40 and how it connects to CPG

  4. Walmart and Muse are about to launch the first agent-to-agent commerce integration

  5. Kyle Fitzpatrick, from Paperboy Ventures, created the first CPG physical newspaper (you might recognize one of the authors 😃)

  6. Breaking down a CPG brand architecture with the founder of a brand who happens to be a brand expert

  7. Specialty Foods Association, which puts on the Fancy Foods conferences, announced its 2027 trend forecasts

  8. Gen Z uses AI daily but feels guilty about it

  9. US vs Europe: CPG edition, what is different and what is the same?

  10. How can brands avoid making costly mistakes by entering the wrong retailer?

Events:

  • Thursday, December 3, 4:00 PM - 6:00 PM - From Prompt to Checkout: An Afternoon for Shopify Operators (sign up here)

  • Thursday, December 3, 6:00 PM - 9:00 PM - The Holiday Mixer (sign up here)

  • Friday, December 4, 9:00 AM - 1:00 PM -The Influence by Superfiliate: Coffee & Cowork (sign up here)

Ad:

Why are so many brands shifting ad spend to CTV?

For marketers who want a presence in streaming, Roku is the obvious place to go. With 47% of all streaming time in the US, it has more reach than every competitor. Discover how Roku Ads Manager can spread your message across 100+ premium apps in a single, self-serve ad buy.

Was this forwarded to you? Sign up here.

Have an idea or want to chat? Respond to this email.

Is the email not reaching your inbox? Try this trick.